A volunteer mentoring program is free and pairs a young person with a screened volunteer for a long-term relationship, often meeting a few times a month. A paid mentor is a professional who meets weekly or more on specific goals, with check-ins between sessions and updates for parents. Choose a volunteer program for a caring adult over time; choose paid mentoring for structure, speed and focus.
Blackburn Mentoring is a paid one-on-one option for teens 13 and up and young adults, by video nationwide and in person in Los Angeles; it starts with a free intro call and a mentor match within 2 business days. Call (888) 305-5422. The comparison below applies to any paid or volunteer option.
Paid mentor vs volunteer program at a glance
| Volunteer mentoring program | Paid one-on-one mentor | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to the family | Free | A fee, based on how often you meet |
| Who the mentor is | A screened, trained volunteer | A professional mentor whose job is mentoring |
| How often | Often a few times a month | Weekly or more, with check-ins between sessions |
| Focus | A caring relationship and new experiences | Specific goals: grades, routines, a job search, a plan |
| Start time | Depends on volunteer availability; waiting lists are common | Usually quick once an intake is done |
| Ages | Most programs serve children and teens | Often teens, college students, young adults and adults |
| Parent role | Program staff check in with families | Progress updates, depending on age and permissions |
| How long it lasts | Often a year or more | Until goals are met, then reviewed |
What the research says: in a national survey, one in three young people reported growing up without a mentor (MENTOR, The Mentoring Effect, 2014). A 2023 MENTOR study found young people today are more than twice as likely to have a program-based mentor as those of thirty years ago, while the gap has persisted (Who Mentored You?, 2023). Both kinds of mentoring help close that gap.
What volunteer mentoring does well
Volunteer mentoring nonprofits do valuable work across the country, and many have supported young people for decades.
- Free to families, which matters a great deal.
- Mentors who choose to show up because they care.
- Long-term relationships, sometimes lasting years.
- Programs that screen mentors and stay in touch with families.
- Exposure to an adult with different experiences and connections.
If your child would benefit from a caring adult over the long run, a local volunteer program is worth contacting first.
What paid mentoring does differently
- Frequency: paid mentors can usually meet weekly or more, plus contact between sessions.
- Focus: sessions center on specific goals, such as grades, a job search or daily routines.
- Timing: paid services can often start sooner than programs with waitlists.
- Age range: many volunteer programs serve younger children and teens; paid mentoring often also covers college students, young adults and professionals.
- Coordination: many paid services, including ours, share progress updates with parents and coordinate with professionals already involved, with permission.
Which fits when
- A younger child who needs a steady, caring adult: a volunteer program.
- A family that cannot add a cost right now: a volunteer program, or school and community resources.
- A teen whose grades are sliding this semester: paid mentoring, for frequency and focus.
- A college student or young adult with no structure: paid mentoring.
- A professional who wants a sounding board in their field: often an informal volunteer mentor through work or alumni networks. See how to find a mentor.
Honest tradeoffs
- Volunteer mentoring is free; paid mentoring is a real expense. Our guide to what affects coaching cost explains the factors.
- Volunteers often meet less often, and schedules may depend on their availability.
- Paid mentoring is a service relationship, so it usually ends when goals are met rather than lasting for years.
- Some volunteer programs have waitlists or eligibility rules by age or area.
- Quality varies in both. Ask how mentors are chosen and supported, and what happens when a match is not working.
If you are on a waitlist
Some volunteer programs have more families waiting than mentors available. While you wait, a few steps can help.
- Ask the school counselor about in-school mentoring, clubs or peer programs.
- Look for a coach, faith leader, relative or family friend who could check in regularly.
- Set up a simple weekly routine at home using our weekly planner for students.
- Stay in touch with the program so you know where you stand.
Questions to ask either option
- How are mentors chosen and matched?
- How often do mentor and mentee meet, and for how long?
- How are parents kept informed?
- What happens if the match does not work?
- What falls outside the mentor’s role, and when do they refer out?
Where Blackburn fits
Blackburn is a paid service. Each client has one dedicated mentor, meets weekly or several times a week, and has text and phone contact between sessions, with rates reviewed on the free intro call. We work with high school students, young adults who feel stuck and families.
We are not the right choice if cost is a barrier or if what a child most needs is a long-term friendship with a caring adult. A volunteer program is the better place to start, and it can be a lasting part of a young person’s life. To weigh whether paid support is worth it for you, read is mentoring worth it.
Mentoring is not therapy or clinical care. If someone needs mental health treatment, a licensed clinician is the right place to start, and a mentor can work alongside them.
Related
- Does my teenager need a mentor?
- Group vs one-on-one mentoring
- Mentor vs coach vs therapist
- Coach vs career coach
- How much does a mentor cost?
- How to choose a mentoring program
Common questions
Are volunteer mentors less qualified than paid ones?
Not necessarily. Many volunteers bring deep life and work experience. The bigger differences are how often you meet, how focused the work is and how quickly you can start.
How do I find a volunteer mentoring program?
Ask your child’s school counselor, local youth organizations or your community center which programs serve your area and age group.
Can a young person have both?
Yes. A long-term volunteer mentor and a shorter, goal-focused paid mentor can complement each other well.
Is a paid mentor better than a volunteer mentoring program?
Neither is better in general. A volunteer program is the right start when cost matters or a young person mainly needs a caring adult over time. A paid mentor fits when you need weekly structure, a quick start and work on specific goals.
Can I hire a mentor for my teen online?
Yes. Blackburn Mentoring is a paid service that works with teens 13 and up, college students and young adults by video anywhere in the United States, and in person in Los Angeles.
Get started
Wondering whether paid mentoring is the right step for your family? Call (888) 305 5422, email contact@blackburnmentoring.com or start with a short assessment. A member of our team reviews every assessment personally and sets up a free intro call.
Last updated .
Free, by video, 20 minutes, with a member of our team. Weekdays 9 to 5 Pacific.