A tutor helps a student understand the material in a subject. An executive function coach helps a student plan, start, organize and submit work across subjects. If grades are falling because assignments are missing or late, coaching may be the better first step, but first find out why the work is not being completed.
Providers use the label “executive functioning tutor” in different ways, so the test is simple: if sessions are spent on content, it is tutoring; if they are spent on planning, habits and systems, it is coaching. This guide covers high school and college students.
Blackburn Mentoring provides one-on-one executive function coaching and mentoring for high school and college students. It is not a subject tutoring service.
At a glance
| Tutor | Executive function coach | |
|---|---|---|
| Teaches | What to learn: a subject or a test | How to get learning done: planning, starting, time, follow-through |
| Focus | One class or one exam | The student’s whole week, across every class |
| A session looks like | Working problems, explaining concepts, practice | Reviewing the calendar and portal, breaking down the next big task, setting times to do it |
| Between sessions | Practice problems | Short check-ins on commitments |
| Success looks like | Higher scores in that subject | Fewer missing assignments, earlier starts, less parent reminding |
| When it ends | Often when the course or test ends | When the student’s own system holds without support |
Read the gradebook first
The pattern of lost points usually tells you which problem you have.
Signs a tutor is the right first step:
- Test and quiz scores are low even when the student studied.
- Homework is turned in on time but is mostly wrong.
- The trouble is in one or two subjects.
- The student can describe the plan but cannot do the problems.
Signs an executive function coach is the right first step:
- Test scores are fine, but zeros for missing work pull the grade down.
- The trouble shows up in many subjects at once.
- Work gets done but not turned in, or turned in late.
- The student does not have a reliable system for tracking what is due this week.
- Long projects start the night before, every time.
- The student struggles to start homework, even when they understand the assignment.
If you checked items on both lists, the student may need both, and the order matters (see below).
What a tutoring session looks like
A tutor reviews the subject material, explains concepts the student does not understand and practices problems or assignments with them. The focus is on understanding and applying the material in a particular class.
What a tutor usually does not do is follow the student through the rest of the week. When the session ends, the student is on their own to schedule practice, remember the history project and get to bed on time.
What an executive function coaching session looks like
An executive function coach and student review the calendar, school portal and upcoming assignments. Together they identify what is missing, break larger tasks into manageable steps and decide when the work will happen. Check-ins between sessions help the student practice following the plan independently.
Over a grading period the student practices the same planning routine until it becomes theirs. Our page on executive function coaching describes the process in more detail.
Questions to ask yourself before hiring either
A few minutes of honest reflection can point you in the right direction:
- When does the trouble start? If your student cannot begin homework, the problem is likely starting and planning. If they begin but get stuck on the problems, it is likely content.
- What do teachers say? Comments like “missing work” and “needs to advocate for himself” point to executive function. Comments like “struggling with the concepts” point to tutoring.
- Is this new? A sudden drop in one class after a strong start suggests a content gap. A slow slide across all classes over a semester suggests the workload has outgrown the student’s systems.
- Who is doing the remembering? If a parent is tracking every due date, the student has not yet built that skill, and a tutor will not build it for them.
High school students
In high school, a parent often sees the problem first in the school portal: a column of missing assignments, or a grade that drops in every class at once. That pattern often points to executive function. A coach works with the student on the portal and calendar, so the student, not the parent, becomes the one who tracks what is due. Tutoring fits better when one course, often a math or science class, is the problem and the rest of the transcript is steady.
Workload jumps, such as the start of high school or junior year, are a common moment for a student who coped fine before to fall behind. That is usually a sign the workload has outgrown the student’s systems, not that the student cannot learn the material. See academic coaching for high school students.
College students
Many colleges offer subject tutoring, writing support and sometimes academic coaching. Before choosing outside help, check what the campus provides. College students manage deadlines across syllabi and course portals, and attendance requirements vary by class. When the main difficulty is planning, starting or submitting work across several courses, ongoing executive function coaching may help. See executive function coaching for college students.
How to choose when a college student’s grades are slipping
Start with why points are being lost. Trouble in one class, with good grades elsewhere, usually points to a tutor or the campus tutoring center. Missing or late work across several classes usually points to a coach, although attendance, health or a content gap can also be behind it. If the student is not going to class or turning work in, a tutor alone cannot fix that. Before a withdrawal deadline or after a semester on academic probation, the advisor and the dean of students office matter as much as outside help.
For broader next steps, see our guides on a college student failing classes and what a W on a transcript means. If anxiety, depression or substance use is part of the picture, the campus counseling center or a clinician comes first.
When to use both, and in what order
Many students benefit from both, but rarely at full intensity at the same time. If a student is behind in five classes, adding a tutor for one of them can add one more appointment to forget. Start with coaching to steady the week, then add tutoring for the subject that still lags once work is coming in on time. If the student is organized but stuck on one course, start with the tutor and add a coach later if the workload grows.
For a broader comparison that includes mentors and academic coaches, see academic coach vs mentor vs executive function coach.
Where Blackburn Mentoring fits
Blackburn Mentoring is not a tutoring service. Our mentors provide one-on-one executive function coaching and mentoring for high school students 13 and up, college students and young adults: planning, starting, follow-through and the habits behind them. Sessions are by video anywhere in the United States or in person in Los Angeles, with text and phone check-ins between sessions. For high school students, a parent or guardian is involved in the mentoring plan. Parents can receive updates when needed, consistent with the student’s age and permissions. For college students 18 and up, updates depend on the student’s permission. Families are welcome to pair us with a tutor they already trust. See executive function coaching and mentor vs tutor.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an executive function coach and a tutor?
A tutor teaches the content of a subject. An executive function coach teaches the skills that get work done in every subject: planning, starting tasks, managing time and following through. Tutoring raises understanding in one class; coaching aims to reduce missing and late work across subjects.
Is an executive functioning tutor the same as an executive function coach?
Not necessarily. Providers use the term “executive functioning tutor” differently. If sessions focus on planning, organization and follow-through, the work is closer to executive function coaching. If they focus on understanding course content, it is tutoring. Ask what a typical session actually covers.
Does my college student need a tutor or a coach?
Look at why points are being lost. Incorrect work in a particular subject points toward tutoring. Missing assignments, poor planning or late submissions across classes point toward executive function coaching. Some students need both. Mental health or learning concerns may also require professional assessment or campus support.
Can a student have a tutor and an executive function coach at the same time?
Yes. When a student is behind in many classes, start with coaching to steady the week, then add a tutor for any subject that still lags. When a student is organized but stuck in one course, start with the tutor.
Does Blackburn Mentoring offer tutoring?
No. Blackburn Mentoring offers one-on-one executive function coaching and mentoring for high school students 13 and up, college students and young adults, by video nationwide or in person in Los Angeles. If a student mainly needs subject help, we will tell you.
Related guides: what an executive function coach does, study skills coaching and does executive function coaching work.
Get started
Not sure which your student needs? Answer a few quick questions, and our team will set up a free intro call.
Last updated .
Free, by video, 20 minutes, with a member of our team. Weekdays 9 to 5 Pacific.